There’s cowardice. There’s contempt. And then there’s Stephen Harper.

There’s not a whole lot that’s printable to say about breaking news this afternoon that the federal Conservatives have, without notice, closed the Kitsilano coast guard base.

Yes, they had announced its looming closure. Yes, they had said repeatedly — and recently — that they would not revoke the decision.

But they also said just a month ago that the base was to close this spring. No precise date had been set.

So to suddenly announce that the gates were being bolted today, without so much as brief advance warning to the crew, to the hundreds of boaters on the water (even in mid-February), or to the thousands of maritime workers who labour on and near the waters of Vancouver daily — well, that’s some kind of contempt for the public.

And some kind of cowardice.

There’s already a widespread, cynical buzz about the closure being scheduled as the provincial budget was being tabled. The idea, I guess, like the tradition of handing out bad-news announcements on Friday afternoons, was to get it over with while everyone was busy looking elsewhere.

Everybody sees life differently. I understand that people of good will can make political decisions that look like total garbage to me. I get that our values, our compasses and our experience steer us in different directions.

But I don’t get, and refuse to accept, that any government elected to serve the people of Canada would get away with something like this — a giant, defiant, bare-knuckled middle finger to the public that pays for its marine safety system to be run as just that, a system that will keep them as safe as reasonably possible.

I also don’t get where all the real politicians have gone, the ones willing to make decisions and announce them and stand by them when people disagree — the ones willing to fall on their swords because they think they’re doing something defensible, not something to sneak in and do in the middle of the night while people are asleep. And then refuse to take calls about.

I don’t get what happened to the elected officials with … what’s that word we used to use in newsrooms … sack. Yeah, that’s it. Sack.

Let’s remember that the base is being closed to save a reputed $700,000 a year. Its rescue function will now — today, tomorrow, who knows? — be filled by a temporary rescue boat stationed at Stanley Park from May to September, and by search-and-rescue staff at the Richmond hovercraft base that is, on a good day, 30 minutes from English Bay and the inner harbour here. It’s an impossible plan. It won’t work. It will come to grief. Anyone who sails knows that.

The coast guard union will be joined by other supporters at 5 p.m. today for a vigil at Kits base, and I guess a protest, outside the base gates.

I’m hoping anyone who can make it will take a moment to set aside their anger at Ottawa and extend a hand of thanks to any of the crew present.

They’ve done a remarkable job, under enormous personal stress, to keep us safe on the water. I think they know where this decision will lead.

I can’t imagine being them today.

I’ve come to know a number of the Kits workers personally over the past 20 years. I interviewed them for years as a maritime reporter, tagged along with them on exercises, listened to them testify at hearings and inquests, held the phone patiently on the odd late night when one of them would call to unload their grief over crazy management decisions.

I watched as some of them refused any personal credit for rescues that required them to risk their own lives to save somebody else’s.

I watched them offer a hand or a hug or a fistful of money to the families of people killed in marine disasters.

They lived, at some cellular level, the motto of the Canadian coast guard: Safety first, service always.

I wish every single one of them well.

About these ads

15 Responses to There’s cowardice. There’s contempt. And then there’s Stephen Harper.

  1. Excellent commentary.

    Truth speaks in your post, the devious silence and cowardice of this action at this time by politicians holding the party line above the real safety needs of the people they are supposedly elected to serve is “unfathomable”.

    Very sad and contemptible.

  2. Thanks, Bill. That’s the tough part for me. I’ll have more to say another day, but the idea that this is being done to save money, based on some set of indefensible national parameters about standardizing service across the country is just … well, a decision that had to be made by someone who doesn’t understand either real-life maritime safety practices or our coast.

  3. Christina…

    Thank you

  4. Grant, thanks. I thought it was too solemn an occasion to toss in the story about how I was skinnydipping one brutally hot day off Stanley Park from my sailboat, and someone called me in as a “body in the water”, and the rigid-hull came screaming out from Kits to check it, and me, out…. I still remember being too embarrassed to even look up. I just swam under the bow of my boat and hid while my passenger explained the situation. To this day, I don’t know who was on that response team. But I can never, ever, ever apologize sufficiently to them for the sight of me dogpaddling around naked.

  5. Great story…Dad and I rescued many boaters, My Dad was the CJOR marine patrol for several years, once per hour on weekdays doing AM radio reports, fishing updates(when we had fish) weather updates, fishing tips and stories from the sea..

    I recall going out to the Malaspina strait at 12:00 midnight, 40 knot winds, 7 foot seas to rescue a boater with engine trouble..

    Dad and Mom tried to save a diver, they were fishing outside of Cree island(west west coast)..Mom spotted a head bobbing, it was a diver, a doctor, he was with his wife diving, the dived on the lee-side of Cree, made their way to the outside of Cree, they ran out of air, the water was to rough, the island rocks too slippery, my Dad roared his boat practically on the rocks to save the woman, they got her, her husband was very difficult to get out of the water, diving gear and weights, Dad managed with herculean strength…

    Coast guard called, a helicopter on route..

    The diver didn`t make it, he was blue, Dad attempted to resuscitate and pumped….Helicopter lifted the diver from Dad`s boat

    5 minutes earlier with help and both would have lived..

    Dad, Mom and I have a dozen more rescues under our hat..

    Christina, one day we must meet for stories and a tip..

    Oh, one more thing..

    Thanks for the visual.

    Good Day

  6. maaikeh@telus.net

    thank you for the information. the closure has nothing to do with money. there is another agenda. I would not be surprized if the property went on the market very shortly and sold to some with connections to the cons. It is about the only property left which has moorage rights and is worth a fortune to a developer.

  7. Maaikeh, thanks, that’s a prospect I’ve thought about a lot, for a couple of years. My boat is at Burrard marina. It used to be tied up two slips from the coast guard base; when the big fire happened, they saved my boat… But yes, the whole downgrade of the civic marina, the question of the native lands behind it, and the Kits base, it all adds up to a very nice piece of property. If you want to talk further privately, feel free to email me at onthewaterfrontblog@gmail.com

    Anyway, we’ll see about the plan, eh?

  8. The callousness of the Harper Government™ never ceases to amaze me.

  9. The flabby disconnected from reality spin from the Prime Minister was nothing short of ridiculous..No wonder he avoids unscripted situations.. to wit (from Canadian Press)

    “The paramouncy of government resources in this area is on public safety and the government is allocating its resources in a way that we believe, based on the advice we have received from the coast guard, that is best in terms of public safety,” the prime minister said.

    “That is to put as many of the resources as we can into actually having rescue boats in the water. That’s where we put our investments going forward.”

    If there’s evidence of a shred of intelligent life hidden in that spew.. would someone please point it out … the paramouncy ???

  10. A great column and one that any politician worth his salt should read monday in the House of commons.l

  11. Shared … in anger! :-(

  12. Harper was Policy Chief for his, Northern Foundation Party of 1989. He was linked with Christian Fundamentalists and other very dubious links. Those of Harper’s ilk, place very little value on human lives.

    Canada is no longer a Democratic country, Canada is now a Dictatorship. We every day Canadians have no rights. Harper’s sellout to Communist China, began way back in Campbell’s reign of terror. Campbell gave Harper permission, to force the Enbridge pipeline into BC. Harper could care less about a dirty Bitumen pipe burst. Nor does he care about a, massive oil tanker spill. He would sail right through that oil spill and, wouldn’t even turn a hair.

    Harper and Gordon Campbell worked hand in hand for, the destruction of BC. Campbell thieved and sold our assets, resources and our resource jobs, to China long ago. China sued in BC, to take the mining jobs. Harper’s Omnibull-S-Bill said they could. Chinese miners earn, $800 per month. There are nine new mines and mine expansions going into Northern BC. Wonder who, will get those jobs? China also places, very little value on their peoples lives either.

    Harper can afford an, Ambassador for Religion Freedom. Harper just sees no advantage for himself, saving peoples lives on the sea. How much is time of the essence is say, a fire on any watercraft? Any sinking vessel? I guess it only makes sense to Harper, to close the busiest Search and Rescue Base there is. After all, the BC citizens and the F.N. people oppose Harper’s Enbridge pipeline and the dirty tar tankers. We opposed the HST as well. This won’t be the last kick in the face, we will get from Harper either. Christy works for Harper, as Campbell did before her. She too supports Harper’s give-a-way, of our mining jobs. You notice, her job plans are for China too.

    Harper the dictator, will warn BC of nothing. Not even if it meant, life would be lost at sea. Count on it.

  13. Thanks for keeping the conversation going, folks.

  14. Pingback: So the hasty Kits base closure isn’t so much about cynicism. It’s about Celsius. | On The Waterfront

Feel free to leave a comment. Because a lively opinion is the brown sugar on the porridge of life, right?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s